(307) 234-1073 Casper, WY

About Us

The Stengel Insurance Agency provides Auto, Home & Business Insurance in Casper, Rock Springs, Cheyenne and throughout the states of Wyoming, Montana & Colorado.

At the Stengel Agency, we know insurance. Our experienced agents have been finding the best prices and coverages for their clients for years. Whether it be auto insurance, home insurance, motorcycle or boat insurance, RV, business insurance or life and health insurance, there’s a reason our clients stay with us and recommend us so highly.

Quite simply, we always strive to treat our clients the way we would want to be treated ourselves. After carefully assessing your individual insurance needs, we’ll go to work searching our many companies to find for you the right coverage at the lowest possible price. It is our goal to be the best insurance agency you have ever had, and the last you will ever need.

The Stengel Agency got its start in the fall of 2000 when 2 veteran agents, Jim Stengel and Caryn Schulenberg, decided to split away from their old, captive, one size fits all insurance company and start a new Independent Agency. We knew exactly what our clients wanted and needed, but couldn’t provide it under the highly regulated, stiff, pricey and limited options our former company allowed to us. The only way we could really take good care of our clients needs was to split away and go independent.

Now, we can search through many companies to find just the right fit at the best possible price. We take great pride and satisfaction knowing that our clients are well protected and that we have also saved them money. Now with Amy Royce and her daughter Shai on board, we may not be the biggest agency in Casper, but we are one of the most respected. And that says a lot for what we can do for you!